Valuation Follows Story: Why Storytelling is More Than Just a Soft Skill
We’ve all felt it: quiet frustration when the numbers say one thing, but the market sees something else. You know your company is delivering. The strategy is sound. The results are there. So why isn’t the valuation keeping pace?
More often than not, the gap isn’t in the performance. It’s in the perception. And that’s where storytelling comes in.
Storytelling Isn’t Fluff – It’s Function
In today’s capital markets, storytelling isn’t a nice-to-have; it’s a strategic imperative. Passive investing, algorithmic trading and high-frequency models mean much of the market’s perception is being shaped by digital signals – the words and data points scraped from earnings call transcripts, press releases and web copy.
If those signals aren’t telling a clear, cohesive and credible story, your company could be misunderstood – or even worse, overlooked.
As IROs, we know that valuation is influenced by far more than financials. It’s shaped by what people believe a company stands for and where it’s headed. Belief is built on connection. And that’s what storytelling does.
The Real Power of Storytelling: Creating Clarity and Conviction
Management may feel the company is undervalued, and often that’s correct – but not always for the reasons management assumes. A common blind spot is communication. If the story isn’t being told well – or isn’t being told at all – the market fills in the blanks. That’s where the IRO steps in to build engagement that leads to understanding; an understanding that leads to more accurate valuation.
To that end, storytelling is a productivity tool hiding in plain sight. Done right, it minimizes confusion, saves time by increasing effectiveness at getting your key messages across, and makes your investment thesis memorable.
A well-told story connects the dots between strategy, performance and purpose. It creates a throughline that helps analysts, investors and even internal teams understand not just what the company does – but why it matters. This ultimately leads to better comprehension and stronger conviction.
Whether it’s a data visualization, a CEO quote, or a line in a press release, every message is a chance to reinforce your bigger picture.
The Neuroscience Behind Why Storytelling Works
Here’s where this gets fascinating. Storytelling doesn’t just feel good – it changes brains.
Thanks to neuroplasticity, our brains are constantly rewiring based on the information and stimuli we receive. Repetition of key messages across multiple channels creates new neural pathways. That’s how familiarity and trust are built over time.
So, when you consistently tell a cohesive, emotionally resonant story across your IR website, earnings materials, media interviews and social platforms, you’re not just reinforcing your brand. You’re literally shaping how investors think about you.
And in a market where capital allocation is as much about perception as performance, that’s powerful.
How to Tell the Story: Practical Tips for IROs
This isn’t about spin. It’s about structure. Storytelling in IR is about clarity, not creativity for its own sake.
Here are some ways to put storytelling into action – through what you say and how you say it:
- Earnings Calls: Use a narrative arc. Start with the macro context, then zoom in to company-specific performance. End with a forward-looking message that reinforces your strategic direction. Consider tone, pacing and energy; non-verbal cues influence perception just as much as words.
- Investor Presentations: Apply the ‘Martini Approach’: start broad, go specific, end strong. Each slide should flow into the next like chapters in a book, with deliberate pacing and connective logic that guides your audience. Keep delivery focused and intentional – remember that body language, voice modulation and slide design all reinforce your message.
- Data Visualization: Turn complex or often boring data into clear, compelling visuals. Use charts, graphs and images that highlight the most important metrics. Keep it clean, labeled and focused – clarity and context matter more than detail. Visuals aren’t just decoration; they’re tools to speed up understanding and build credibility.
- Social Media and Owned Channels: Share authentic, personal stories from leadership, employees or customers. These stories humanize the business and create emotional connection.
- Corporate Reporting: Treat this like more than a compliance exercise. Every section – from ESG to operations to governance – should ladder up to a consistent, values-aligned narrative. Even the required management commentary can carry more context and clarity than many companies tend to give it.
Every piece of your IR narrative – from presentations to ESG updates – should align with a consistent, credible storyline. Done well, this creates clarity not only for analysts and institutional investors, but also for digital signals picked up by algorithms and passive flows, which increasingly shape market perception.
Managing the Storytellers
Let’s be honest: clearly not everyone is a great storyteller and many executives overestimate how clear or compelling they sound.
IROs play a key role in guiding the narrative and advising executives on how to deliver the story. That means:
- Gently challenging assumptions when needed;
- Grounding messaging in facts and credibility; and
- Aligning leadership around a shared story that is honest, strategic and engaging.
Sometimes this involves managing up. Use peer and other market examples to demonstrate how storytelling impacts market perception. If management is hesitant, point to how admired companies – whether in your sector or beyond – are using narrative to stand out.
This work begins behind the scenes. Conduct dedicated messaging sessions to align leadership on key themes. Develop a messaging platform with clear, repeatable language to ensure consistency across communications. Establish content pillars that tie back to your investment thesis and long-term strategy. These serve as guideposts for every touchpoint – earnings calls, investor meetings, and media interactions alike.
When appropriate, consider media training to help executives become more confident, compelling storytellers. Training provides the structure and support needed to elevate delivery without sacrificing authenticity.
Part of guiding the narrative is ensuring it's grounded in what's already been publicly disclosed, so every audience – from analysts to algorithms – is reacting to the same accurate picture.
Finally, remember that every engagement opportunity – analyst meetings, investor days, earnings calls – is more than a data dump. These are moments to reinforce your strategic arc, connect macro to micro, and proactively shape how your company is interpreted across both human and algorithmic lenses. This is especially critical in today’s landscape, where narrative coherence plays an increasingly central role in how companies are interpreted – not just by people, but by the AI systems and digital signals that influence capital flows.
Consistent, strategic storytelling across channels is now essential to being seen – and understood – by the market.
Trust is the Real Alpha
At the end of the day, investors allocate capital where they see clarity, consistency and conviction.
Storytelling, when done well, builds all three. But without it, even strong performance can be overlooked. If your story isn’t engaging, valuation can be erroneous, not because the company isn’t delivering, but because people don’t fully grasp what it’s trying to achieve or how it fits in the broader market context. Good storytelling is the thread that ties together your performance, purpose and potential. It builds trust. And trust, more than any single metric, is what drives long-term value.
IROs don’t just share information. We shape understanding. In today’s market, that’s what moves the needle.
More About IR focus